It's really a matter of whether you want to safeguard your packed items from getting crushed or protect the exterior of the suitcase from superficial blemishes . The T+L team tested at least five bags per brand on our winners list to ensure a broad sample size. We tested underseat luggage, checked luggage, and carry-on luggage and gave each individual bag a score based on its capacity, design, durability, maneuverability, and overall value. The T+L team tried upwards of 170 pieces of luggage in the lab, our New York City testing facility. We tested several models from many top-rated brands, performing a range of assessments to evaluate the capacity, maneuverability, durability, design, and overall value. The storage space is efficient and practical, using mesh dividers and cross-straps to keep your belongings safe. With a book-style opening, this compact case offers 2 good-sized compartments that are just right for packing your swimsuit, flip flops, and all your other vacation gear. On the other hand, soft-sided suitcases are typically lighter-weight and more flexible, so you can often pack more in them. After testing both types, we can tell you they're often just as durable as hardside options. They’ve actually received pretty good reviews among the parents and don’t cost too much, so we’d suggest checking them out. Despite being a bit more expensive, suitcases that have TSA locks will most likely last longer since the TSA won’t have to destroy them to check your possessions. Unfortunately, this kind of coverage is the standard for most suitcase brands. The top handle has a comfortable grip and a push-button for convenience. The spacious interior storage compartment allows for efficient packing. A suitcase of this size needs wheels you can depend upon, and the single-spinner wheels that allow for 360 degrees of upright rolling certainly won’t let you down. If you’re still on the fence about whether or not this carry-on is right for you, the more than 5,000 five-star ratings speak for themselves. Shoppers say it’s lightweight, easy to maneuver and surprisingly durable. Some negative reviews have talked about miscommunication and difficulties with customer support. The reviews for their luggage and sets usually cross the 4-star rating, meaning that most customers are happy with their purchase. Each bag was weighed, then packed with enough clothes and personal items to get through a four-day trip . Of the eight we tried, six earned a score over 4, with an average overall rating of 4.1 out of 5. We were impressed by how well they stood up to our shoves and bat swings — virtually no dents or scratches to speak of. This, like the American Tourister case, features a less durable ABS shell that dented quickly and retained lasting marks after our tests.